Gatekeeping Under Pressure: Why Supervisors are Inheriting Students Who Weren’t Ready with Dr. Ashley Durbin
Badass Therapists Building Practices That Thrive #210 Gatekeeping Under Pressure: Why Supervisors are Inheriting Students Who Weren't Ready with Dr. Ashley Durbin
Clinical Supervision Gatekeeping Starts Where You Are
I've heard the following complaint a lot from supervisors: How did this person graduate?
They're sitting across from a brand-new associate with a master's degree, yet the clinical skills they expected to see simply are not there. Suddenly, clinical supervision gatekeeping feels less like professional development and more like being handed responsibility for something that happened long before the supervisee walked through the door.
Dr. Ashley Stephens Durbin and I talked about why that can happen. Faculty may be dealing with institutional pressure around graduation rates, student evaluations, job security, and the realities of adjunct teaching. Ashley described what it is like when professors are expected to hold students accountable while knowing that poor student evaluations may affect whether they are invited back to teach. That context matters. It does not mean professors do not care about competency. It means supervisors may be receiving graduates from systems where the people responsible for earlier gates did not always have complete control over those gates.
That leaves us with an uncomfortable truth. You cannot go backward and redesign the graduate program. You can only decide what you are going to do with the supervisee sitting in front of you now.
Gatekeeping Is a Boundary, Not a Punishment
The word gatekeeping makes people uncomfortable. I understand why. Ashley and I are both against unnecessary barriers to this profession. We want creative clinicians. We want different personalities, backgrounds, approaches, and modalities. The goal is not to turn every therapist into the same square peg.
But a gate is still a boundary. As a supervisor, eventually you put your name on paperwork saying you believe this person is ready to move forward. That signature means something. It means you are willing to recognize this supervisee as a future colleague. That is not about whether you like them. It is about whether they can demonstrate the competencies required to serve clients safely.
I think this distinction helps. A supervisee can be different from you without being deficient. They can practice differently from you without practicing incompetently. The question is not, Would I do it this way? The question is, Can I observe and document the skill I am responsible for evaluating?
When a Supervisee Is Missing Skills, Get Specific
Years ago, I supervised an associate who was really struggling to run groups. I kept wondering what I was missing. I was a newer supervisor, so naturally I questioned myself. Eventually, I had the conversation with her and discovered something important. She had never completed a standalone group course. She had read a chapter on groups, but she had not practiced the skill during practicum or internship. Her job was essentially her first experience running one.
Once I knew that, we had something we could work with. I could give her material to read, help her observe groups in the community, and spend supervision time strengthening those skills. The problem moved from a vague feeling of something is wrong to a specific competency gap that we could address.
That is what I want supervisors to notice. You cannot measure “annoying.” You cannot evaluate “I just have a bad feeling.” You can evaluate whether a supervisee demonstrates reflection, case conceptualization, documentation, professional communication, appropriate intervention skills, or whatever specific competency concerns you. Your observations must eventually become words that somebody else could understand.
Clinical Supervision Gatekeeping Requires Evaluation and Remediation
When you realize a supervisee is not meeting an expectation, go back to your system. I teach supervisors to think in terms of the OER triad: orientation, evaluation, and remediation. Your orientation establishes expectations. Your evaluation tells both of you where the supervisee stands. Remediation creates a structured opportunity for development when a deficit appears.
This is why evaluation cannot live entirely in conversation. If you are concerned about a supervisee's performance, your supervision notes and evaluations should reflect the actual skill you are observing. Then talk with the supervisee. Tell them what you are seeing. Give them an opportunity to respond. Determine what training, practice, observation, consultation, or other measurable behavior could demonstrate improvement.
This connects directly with my guidance on building a supervision paperwork system that includes contracts, evaluation, documentation, and remediation and what supervisors should look for in a clinical supervision contract. Expectations should not become visible for the first time when someone is already in trouble. The strongest systems make evaluation and accountability predictable from the beginning.
Supervisees Need Permission to Ask Hard Questions Too
This responsibility does not belong only to supervisors. If you are an associate listening to this and your supervisor has never identified an area for growth, ask. You do not need to assume that silence means you are doing everything perfectly. Sit down and say, Where am I lacking? What do I need to improve? What are you seeing that I may not see yet?
And sometimes the mismatch goes the other direction. Maybe you learned a modality your supervisor does not know. Maybe the field has changed since your supervisor completed graduate school. Maybe your workplace operates under parameters neither of you anticipated. Supervision has to leave room for curiosity in both directions. A supervisor can say, “This is how I learned it. Show me what you learned. Let's figure out what the standard requires.”
If the supervisor truly cannot guide you in an area central to the clinician you want to become, that may be information too. Finding someone with the appropriate expertise is not betrayal. Good supervision should help you develop competence, even when that means bringing another knowledgeable professional into your learning.
You Did Not Create the Upstream Problem, but You Own Your Checkpoint
Supervisors, here is the practical step I want you to take this week. Look at your documentation and your evaluations. If you have concerns about a supervisee, ask yourself whether another professional could identify the concern from what you wrote. If all you have is a feeling, translate that feeling into an observable skill and start there.
Then have the conversation. Do not wait until the supervisee is twenty hours from completion to finally name a problem that has bothered you for months. Evaluate. Document. Remediate when appropriate. Consult with other supervisors when you need perspective. Community matters because gatekeeping can feel very lonely when the decision carries real consequences for another person.
You did not create every weakness that arrived at your door. You are not responsible for repairing higher education. But clinical supervision gatekeeping means taking responsibility for the checkpoint you actually control. That is not cruelty. It is one of the ways we protect clients, support developing clinicians, and protect the integrity of the profession.
Where This Blog Connects
- What Should Graduate Students Know About Clinical Supervision?
- How to Evaluate a Supervisee (Without Winging It)
- Solution Based Supervision
Want to learn more? Check out this month’s free bonus resource from Kate Walker Training.
If you are responsible for deciding whether a supervisee is ready to move forward, your systems matter. Grab the Supervision Onboarding Checklist to review the systems you have in place before concerns arise.
If supervision decisions feel heavy, you do not have to figure them out alone. Inside the Step It Up Membership, we work through supervision systems, documentation, evaluation, and ethical decision-making so you can lead with more clarity and consistency.
Blog post by Kate Walker, Ph.D., LPC-S, LMFT-S
Creator of Texas’s first fully online 40-Hour LPC/LMFT Supervisor Training Course.
Kate is the founder of Kate Walker Training, where she helps counselors, supervisors, and practice owners build sustainable, ethical, and profitable businesses.
Ready to grow your supervision practice? Check out the Supervisor Training Courses.
This post is a written summary of a podcast episode hosted by Dr. Kate Walker. We use AI to help format the transcript and check for clarity and spelling, turning spoken content into an easier-to-read format.

